- Category: Brokerage Business
Is Forex Trading Profitable? Retail Loss Rates, Trading Costs and What Brokers Run Behind Them

Forex trading is profitable for a minority of retail traders, and regulators have measured how small that minority is. When the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) reviewed national data in 2018, between 74% and 89% of retail CFD accounts typically lost money, with average losses per client of €1,600 to €29,000. The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) found in its 2017 review that 72% of clients trading CFDs lost money, and 63% of those trading currency-pair CFDs. Brokers in the UK and the EU must now publish their own loss percentage, recalculated every three months over the previous 12 months, and US retail forex dealers publish the share of accounts that were profitable in each quarter. The reasons are mechanical: every round trip pays a spread or commission, which lifts the win rate a strategy needs just to break even, and leverage turns a run of small losses into a closed account. On the other side of each trade, the same numbers decide what a broker earns, what it hedges and what it must disclose.
What regulators' data says about retail forex profitability
The most reliable figures come from supervisors, because they can compel brokers to hand over account-level data. Three data sets cover most of the retail market.
According to ESMA's March 2018 announcement, national regulators' analyses of CFD trading across different EU jurisdictions found 74–89% of retail accounts typically losing money, with average losses per client between €1,600 and €29,000. That finding underpinned the leverage limits, margin close-out rule, negative balance protection and standardised risk warning agreed by ESMA's Board of Supervisors on 23 March 2018.
In Australia, ASIC's 2017 review found that 72% of clients who traded CFDs lost money, and 63% of those trading CFDs over currency pairs, at a time when leverage on foreign exchange CFDs ran as high as 500 to 1. According to ASIC, during five volatile weeks in March and April 2020, the retail clients of 13 CFD issuers made a net loss of more than A$774 million; over 1.1 million positions were closed out under margin rules, and more than 15,000 accounts fell into negative balance owing A$10.9 million in total.
In the United States, the clearest evidence comes from a natural experiment. When the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) capped retail forex leverage at 50:1 on major pairs and 20:1 on others in October 2010, Rawley Heimer and Alp Simsek compared US traders with European traders who kept higher leverage. According to their study for the National Bureau of Economic Research, the cap cut trading volume by 23% and reduced high-leverage traders' losses by about 40%; before the cap, the average high-leverage US trader lost 44% a month.
These figures describe retail accounts trading CFDs and rolling spot forex with a broker. They say nothing about bank dealing desks or institutional funds, and they count accounts, not money.
Where a broker's published loss rate comes from
Since 2018 the loss rate has moved from regulators' reports onto brokers' own websites. Four points matter before reading any broker's figure:
- UK and EU brokers publish a firm-specific percentage of retail accounts that lost money, recalculated every three months.
- US dealers publish the opposite measure, the share of accounts that were profitable, one calendar quarter at a time.
- Australia does not require a firm-specific figure; ASIC publishes aggregate findings instead.
- Every regime counts accounts rather than money, and every one includes trading costs.
| Regime | What the broker publishes | Period and frequency | When an account counts as losing |
|---|---|---|---|
| UK: FCA COBS 22.5.6R | Percentage of retail investor accounts that lose money, inside a standard risk warning | Recalculated every three months over the previous 12 months | Realised plus unrealised net profit below zero, after all costs, fees and commissions |
| EU: ESMA 2018 method, now national rules | The same firm-specific loss percentage, for example under CySEC's permanent measures | Quarterly calculation covering the preceding 12 months | Realised and unrealised net profits negative, including all charges, fees and commissions |
| US: CFTC 17 CFR 5.5(e) and 5.18(i) | Number of non-discretionary accounts and the percentages profitable and not profitable | Each calendar quarter, with the four most recent in the risk disclosure | Realised and unrealised result, minus fees and commissions, plus interest income |
| Australia: ASIC product intervention order | No firm-specific percentage; ASIC dropped the issuer-specific warning it had proposed | Not required | ASIC publishes aggregate findings from issuer data instead |
The UK rule sets the detail. Under COBS 22.5.6R, the calculation leaves out accounts that held no open position during the period and ignores deposits and withdrawals, and the firm must keep the records behind it for five years. The US rule works from the other direction: 17 CFR 5.18(i) requires a dealer to compute realised and unrealised gains or losses on every retail forex account open during the quarter, subtract all fees, commissions and other charges, and add interest income.
Dealers file the US result with the National Futures Association (NFA) in a Forex Quarterly Report due within 17 business days of the quarter's end, and must provide five years of the quarterly figures to any customer who asks.
The European rules began as ESMA's temporary decisions. They expired at the end of 31 July 2019 because most national regulators had adopted permanent measures at least as stringent. ESMA's opinion on the Cypriot measures records that the Cyprus Securities and Exchange Commission (CySEC) version, due to take effect on 2 October 2019, matches ESMA's apart from minor amendments to the standard risk warnings.
A 12-month UK or EU percentage and a single-quarter US percentage measure different windows, so the two cannot be compared directly. Within one regime, comparing brokers is straightforward, because every firm runs the same calculation.
Why most accounts lose: costs set a hurdle on every trade
A trade that wins as often as it loses, by the same distance, loses money once costs are paid. The spread and any commission are charged on every round trip whatever the outcome, so they shrink each win and enlarge each loss. With a profit target of T pips, a stop of S pips and a round-trip cost of C pips, the win rate needed to break even is (S + C) ÷ (T + S).
The worked example below applies that formula to a cost of 1.2 pips per round trip, an illustrative figure for a spread plus commission on a major pair:
| Target and stop | Cost as share of target | Break-even win rate |
|---|---|---|
| 5 pips and 5 pips | 24% | 62% |
| 10 pips and 10 pips | 12% | 56% |
| 20 pips and 20 pips | 6% | 53% |
| 30 pips and 30 pips | 4% | 52% |
| 20-pip target, 10-pip stop | 6% | 37% |
The shorter the trade, the larger the share of each move the cost consumes. Frequency compounds it: a trader who opens and closes one standard lot of EUR/USD five times a day pays about $60 a day at 1.2 pips, since one pip on 100,000 euros is worth $10. Over 250 trading days that is $15,000 in costs, more than the whole of a $10,000 account, before a single forecast has been right or wrong. The pip values and lot sizes behind that arithmetic are set by the broker's contract specifications.
How leverage turns small losses into closed accounts
Leverage does not change the odds of an individual trade; it changes how many losing trades an account survives. In the UK, COBS 22.5.11R requires retail clients to post at least 3.33% of the exposure on a major currency pair, a ceiling of 30:1. When net equity falls below 50% of the margin requirement, COBS 22.5.13R obliges the firm to close positions as soon as market conditions allow, and COBS 22.5.17R limits a retail client's liability to the funds in the account. In the US, 17 CFR 5.9 sets the security deposit at no less than 2% of notional value on major pairs and 5% on others, the source of the 50:1 and 20:1 limits.
Australia shows the effect in numbers. Its order applied from 29 March 2021, at 30:1 on major pairs, 20:1 on minor pairs, gold and major indices, 10:1 on other commodities and minor indices, 5:1 on shares and 2:1 on crypto-assets. In the first six months, ASIC observed a 91% reduction in aggregate net losses on retail accounts, from A$372 million to A$33 million a quarter on average, and 51% fewer loss-making accounts per quarter, using data from more than 60 CFD issuers. Lower leverage did not make retail trading profitable; it made losses smaller and slower. The interplay between a trader's own limits and the broker's close-out is covered in more detail in how stops, free margin and close-outs interact, and the cross-regime caps in the current currency leverage rules.
What the broker earns when clients lose
A retail trader's loss does not vanish; it lands somewhere, and where depends on how the broker handles the trade. ASIC put a figure on it. In 2018, licensed issuers in Australia received gross trading revenue of A$1.5 billion from CFDs, which, according to ASIC, "can largely be attributed to a combination of net client losses and fees and costs charged to clients".
- A-book: the broker passes the trade to a liquidity provider and earns the spread mark-up or commission; the client's result does not touch the broker's trading profit and loss.
- B-book: the broker is the counterparty and keeps the position; a client's net loss is the broker's gain, and a client's profit is the broker's cost.
- Hybrid: the broker internalises part of its flow and hedges the exposures it does not want to carry.
A published loss rate is therefore also a description of a broker's revenue mix. Negative balance protection moves the tail of a client's loss onto the broker, so a B-book broker carries gap risk itself, and the revenue it books depends on how its clients trade. The mechanics of each revenue line are set out in how forex brokers earn from spreads, commissions, swaps and the B-book. Regulation reaches this side too: Heimer and Simsek found that the 2010 US leverage cap reduced brokerages' operating capital by 25%, while leaving the relative bid-ask prices they charged unchanged. Copy trading changes the picture again, because one strategy's result is repeated across many accounts at once, as the analysis of whether offering copy trading pays for brokers explains.
What a brokerage runs behind the loss-rate figure
For an operator, the regulatory percentage is a data task before it is a disclosure. To produce the UK or EU figure, a broker needs, for every retail account and every 12-month window, realised profit and loss, unrealised profit and loss at the end of the window, and every spread, commission, swap and fee charged; it then excludes accounts that held no open position and strips out deposits and withdrawals. The US calculation needs the same inputs per calendar quarter, plus interest income. Both feed a public number recalculated every quarter.
The same account-level data runs the dealing desk. A B-book or hybrid broker watches net client exposure per symbol, because the part of client flow it has not hedged is the part whose result it keeps.
In the WxTrade back-office sandbox, the Trading Account screen lists balance, credit, margin, free margin, profit, equity and leverage for each client account, and the Summary screen nets buy volume, sell volume, net volume and profit per symbol beside a column headed Uncovered. Its Report section offers topics including Trading Account Leverage Selection and Average Individual P/L Summary, grouped by date, week, month, quarter or year and downloadable as PDF or Excel. The percentage itself still has to be calculated to each regulator's definition, and the brokerage remains responsible for its own disclosures.
Frequently asked questions
How many people make a profit from Forex trading?
The answer is set broker by broker and period by period, and the published figure needs careful reading. A UK or EU warning that 74% of accounts lose money means 26% of active retail accounts finished the 12 months at zero or above, because the rule counts an account as losing only when its result is below zero; it does not mean 26% made a meaningful profit. The US measure counts profitable accounts directly, so an account that finishes flat cannot count as profitable. Both measures count accounts rather than people or money, so one large winning account weighs the same as one that made a few dollars.
How much can you make with $1000 in forex per day?
There is no fixed daily figure: the account limits the position, and the position sets the size of every gain and loss. Under the UK's 3.33% margin rule for major pairs, $1,000 supports at most about $30,000 of EUR/USD exposure. At a rate of 1.08, one pip on that position is worth about $2.78, so a 20-pip move adds or removes about $56, or 5.6% of the account, and each round trip at 1.2 pips costs about $3.33. Under the US 2% deposit rule, the ceiling is $50,000 of exposure, or about $4.63 a pip. The arithmetic that makes a $56 day possible makes a $56 loss equally possible, and the cost is paid either way.
Is forex skill or luck?
The data point most clearly to position size. In Heimer and Simsek's sample, traders in the highest fifth of leverage use had net monthly returns 30 to 40 percentage points worse than those in the lowest fifth before the 2010 US cap, and the cap improved the high-leverage group's relative performance by 18 percentage points a month. Short windows add noise: a single-quarter US figure can include accounts that were profitable for one quarter but not across a full year.
Is there a 100% profitable strategy?
No. Costs alone rule it out for any strategy that can lose a trade. A strategy that takes 5-pip profits against 15-pip stops needs to win 81% of its trades to break even at 1.2 pips of cost; winning 75% of the time, it loses about 1.2 pips per trade on average. In the UK, any marketing of CFD trading by a provider must carry the provider's own loss percentage in its risk warning, whatever the strategy promises.


